 |
What are those peppers talking about?! Scientists are aiming to find out if plants can communicate using sound, and
it looks like they're getting closer to knowing the answer. Photo courtesy of Creative Loafing Tampa. |
by douglas reeser, june 15, 2012
The other day, I noticed a headline in one of my news feeds that proclaimed: "
Plants Can Talk to Each Other and Respond to Sound." I was immediately reminded of the Michael Pollan book,
The Botany of Desire, which posits that plants have had an agenda of their own as they have evolved with humans. This agenda, namely to increase their chance of propagation and survival, had a great impact on human society and development. Certain crops were especially successful - think of plants like corn, wheat or apples that have been grown in massive numbers around the globe. In essence, Pollan gave plants agency; he demonstrated that there may be more going on than meets the eye when it comes to the plant kingdom.
We have known that plants do respond to sound. For instance, studies have shown greater growth among plants fed a steady diet of classical music. I decided to look for the original study referenced in the news (and found another one too!), and while it's true that science is looking at plant communication, their ability to talk is less certain. The article referenced
in the news is from the journal
Trends in Plant Science, and examines the phenomenon of bioacoustics. It reasons that since all kinds of animals, reptiles, and insects have the ability to sense, act on, and send sounds and vibrations, perhaps plants do as well. Surprisingly, the authors did not offer any new evidence or study, only that they felt bioacoustics among plants was a promising field about which little is known, and that merits further study. From the article:
We are growing increasingly doubtful of the idea that all acoustic emissions by plants are the mere result of the abrupt release of tension in the water-transport system...Recent evidence illustrates that the young roots of corn generate structured, spike-like, acoustic emissions. To date, the production mechanisms and adaptive value of such acoustic emissions remain elusive, yet in the past two decades several studies have pointed to the phenomenological importance of sound and vibrations in plant physiology...We propose that the potential adaptive functions of sound in the life of plants have not been explored to their full potential, leaving serious gaps in our current understanding of the sensory and communicative complexity of these organisms.
A little disappointed that the study didn't exactly show that plants are communicating with sounds (and surprised that the news media would declare a non-finding as a new discovery), I decided to see if anyone had shown that plants "talk" audibly with each other. I came across another study, published earlier this year in PLoS ONE (this one is open access and
can be read here), that offers references to a number of studies that demonstrate various types of plant communication and adaptation, and then goes on to discuss the authors' study that sought to demonstrate communication through sound among chili pepper plants. I wondered if their language is as hot as they are!.
In this study, titled "
Out of Sight but Not out of Mind: Alternative Means of Communication in Plants,"
the authors were able to show that plants do communicate - and in a way other than through physical contact (above or below ground), or through chemical or light-mediated signals. They showed that plants can actually sense their neighbors, and react to some plants differently than others. They even grow differently based on their neighboring plants. But.... the authors did not show that plants use sound to communicate!
The authors conclude with the following:
Sound may be another modality by which plants exchange information. Decades of scientific research has measured and described sound waves produced by plants as well as the effects of sound on plants such as changes in germination and growth rates as well as physiological responses. Moreover, both emission and detection of sound may have adaptive value in plants and while we still don’t know how sound is perceived in that we are yet to identify receptor mechanisms and study their function, we have clear evidence about plants’ ability of detecting vibrations and exhibiting a selective sensitivity on the basis of which they modify their behavior.
So it looks like we're not yet quite sure if plants can talk. We know they communicate in a number of ways, and we know sound can influence their growth. We know they can make sounds, but we aren't sure what for. It would appear that we are getting closer to finding out. All I know is that I'll keep talking to my plants and now I'll be wondering what they're saying about me!
